Combating the myth that creativity 

is linked with mental illness!

The belief that creative people are more likely to suffer from mental illness, is an ancient notion that has transcended through the years and has long been part of our popular culture. The tortured artist or the visionary genius who succumbs to his/her own personal demons, is an image that is perhaps a little too familiar.   However, how legitimate is this concept ? Are creative people really prone to increased mental health issues? Or is being “creative” actually the coping mechanism to improve mental health?

Reverse the stigma

Previous studies, namely recognised as being poor and often subject to bias, have shown a link between creativity and mental illness. This could be a result of artists and writers who kill themselves often becoming high profile news items, and hence distorting the truth.  Artists and writers who live contented and well-balanced lifestyles are likely to attract less attention.

The study

Researchers from Gothenburg University and Uppsaala University in Sweden, sought to distinguish the association between creativity and mental disorder and whether in fact a correlation existed. The study used Swedish health records to identify more than a million people diagnosed with various mental illnesses. They compared the incidence of creative occupations among people with mental illness  against a matched sample of “healthy” people.

The study identified that people in creative professions were significantly less likely than people in other professions, to be diagnosed with schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, depression, anxiety disorders, alcohol abuse, drug abuse, ADHD or to have committed suicide.  The only exception to this was writers.  It was found that people who wrote for a living were twice as likely to suffer from schizophrenia and bipolar disorder and more likely to experience depression and anxiety disorder.

The study was however unable to identify how or why, people with certain creative talents or dispositions would be more likely to experience mental health problems.  For example, does being a writer lead to psychiatric problems? Or, do mental health suffers turn to creative pursuits in order to express themselves?

Arts/Culture as a way to improve mental health

Over the past few decades, research has emerged around the positive impact that arts/culture can have on health, particularly mental health. One such cohort study by a Norwegian researcher, Koenraad Cuypers, performed statistical analysis on the health data of 50,797 Norwegians, as part of the Nord-Trodelag Health Study. The evidence derived from the study showed that participation in cultural/creative activities were significantly associated with good health, good satisfaction with life, low anxiety and depression.  Further information on arts and health studies can be found at The Arts Research Monitor by clicking here http://www.artsresearchmonitor.com/articles.php?catUID=6 

  

In the UK, health professionals and creative artists have worked together for over 25 years using the arts to support healthcare and health promotion. Thus, the importance of arts as a way of improving health must not be underestimated. Whether you are watching a concert, visiting an art gallery, painting, singing, dancing or reading – these creative activities have been recognised as effective ways to decrease stress, create community cohesion and improve social interaction as well as providing a sense of relief from everyday life.

Dr. James Aw, Medical Director of the Medcan Clinic Toronto stated that; “Hobbies and interests outside of work are important for health. New experiences and expanding social networks through art and culture is one piece of the armamentarium in achieving optimal health and living well.”

Early 2013 the RSPH will be holding a new programme, "New Horizons," to address an emerging and widening interest in how the arts can positively impact health and wellbeing.  For further information or to register your interest please contact Gina Mohajer.

To conclude

From the Swedish study, although cause and effect was not ascertained, it nevertheless, highlighted the importance of good mental health and ensuring that those who suffer from mental disorders have the appropriate support and information available to them.    

The RSPH has been involved in promoting the benefits of mental health and demonstrating how this can be achieved. Good mental health is integral for all parts of life, not only for the individual but also for the affects it has on family, relationships, work and society as a whole. Thus, it is imperative for mental health to remain at the top of National and Local Government agenda and policy.

To read RSPH full report on Mental Health please click here.